
Following the recent arrests of activists protesting the Jewish take-over of Palestinian homes in the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood of Jerusalem, the Jerusalem Magistrate's Court ruled that the arrests were illegal. Those arrested included Hagai El-Ad, the Israel director of the Association for Civil Rights.
Sheik Jarrah is one of the most contentious neighborhoods in East Jerusalem. Jewish settlers have been using pre-state property titles dating back to the British Mandate in Palestine to claim ownership. MK Ilan Ghilon (New Movement-Meretz) is not impressed. He said "If settlers can prove the ownership of 28 homes, the Palestinians can prove ownership of 28,000."
Sheikh Jarrah evictions have been condemned by the US. An earlier set of evictions prompted diplomats from the US Embassy to send a protest letter to the Foreign Ministry in Jerusalem.
The police have made a concerted effort to suppress the protests, sometimes by violent means. On a number of occasions demonstrators have been attacked and beaten.
Police treat settlers and ultra-Orthodox less harshly than demonstrators protesting the evictions. The haredim and settlers have been allowed to riot and attack Palestinian residents with little or no interference by police. Activist Avner Inbar who witnessed the police handling of these situations said: "Jerusalem Police see themselves as the operating arm of the settlers in east Jerusalem, and this conduct harms police' credibility." Complaints about police conduct have also been made by professor Amnon Rubinstein and Yehuda Glick, chair of the Organisation for Human Rights on the Temple Mount (OHRTM).
The protests show the best of the Israeli spirit of resistance. Some well known names have been in attendance... former minister and Knesset Chair Avraham Burg, former minister Yossi Sarid, MK Muhamad Barak’e and former MK Uri Avnery. The painter Uri Lifshitz has also been present along with several professors from the Hebrew University.



Author David Grossman who has attended the protests had a few interesting insights:
"There are times when one cannot sit quietly. The settlers and the right - with tremendous help from the government, legal system and financial powers - are abusing the Palestinians in a thousand ways,"
When asked about the the strong turn-out to protest the evictions he said:
"...maybe it's because of the way in which the settlers are taking control of East Jerusalem, which is brazen even by their standards. And maybe because Jerusalem is so symbolic and sensitive that whatever happens here takes on enormous significance."
Uri Avnery, of Gush Shalom told reporters:
“We are protesting against the injustice done to the Palestinian families that were evicted. The eviction is based on the argument that these houses were bought by Jews a hundred years ago, long before the 1948 war. If every Jerusalemite were to get back the house he owned before 1948, half the Jewish population of West Jerusalem would have to be evicted, since they live in houses from which the Arabs were expelled during the 1948 war.”
He added:
“Everybody knows that there will be no peace without a Palestinian state with East Jerusalem as its capital.”
Police say they are going to continue the crackdown despite the refusal of the courts to declare the demos illegal. This attitude isn't surprising. In Israel there is a glaring disparity in the way settler protests are handled as compared to protests on the left. For example 400 cases were brought against settlers protesting the 2005 Gaza Strip disengagement. These people engaged in acts of violence, including throwing acid, garbage and stones at soldiers. But little happened by way of consequence - the cases were closed and the criminal records expunged.
Similar clemency wasn't extended to demonstrators against operation Cast lead in Gaza. Many were arrested and charged. So it's no wonder that right-wing settlers think they can break the law with impunity. They know that in many instances they can get away with criminal behavior.
Attack on Sheikh Jarrah demonstrators - YouTube - here.
Sheikh Jarrah protest - YouTube - here.







