
Simon Barnes has an article on Timesonline that has harsh criticism for Canada's Own The Podium program. Unlike other criticism of the games, the recent Pravda rant for example, Barnes' article at least avoids the kneejerk finger-in-the-face approach, but is nonetheless unsparing in its criticism of Canada's OTP hype. Some might add "rightly so" - except that in the writer's case it's hard not to suspect at least a few sour grapes.
Barnes, who claims he hasn't "a single anti-Canadian molecule in my body" confesses that he ended up rooting for the US in some events because he was so turned off by the Canadians who he describes as "a bunch of mean-spirited, chippy, unsporting losers."
He considers the Own the Podium strategy to be a disaster, not just in terms of results, but also in terms of sportsmanship:
... Own The Podium, a campaign put together with C$117 million (about £72 million) from federal, provincial, territorial and corporate money, has been a failure in terms of medals. In short, it got what it deserved. It deserved to fail because it was conceived in bad sportsmanship and simple envy.
The title has always been the biggest problem, for the athletes it funded and for the message it gave to the world. It told us: we are holding the world’s biggest party. Please come. But we intend to eat all the jelly.
The campaign has been strident, derisive and insulting. Normally, the world takes joy in the success of the home athletes. Freeman’s run in Sydney was as lovely a bit of sport as I’ve seen, and Guo Jingjing, the diver diva, was wonderful in Beijing. But the world has found it hard to enjoy Canada’s successes.
That phrase. Own it. It’s not a Canadianism. It’s an Americanism. It’s a reasonably modern bit of jargon and expresses a highly American mixture of positive thinking and borderline arrogance. By using this phrase, Canada was unambiguously taking on the big neighbour.
Barnes suggests sarcastically that a more apt slogan for the Canadian team effort might have been "Up Yours America". His criticism also extends to the way guest athletes were handled:
Own The Podium didn’t stop at helping Canadians. It also tried to hinder everyone else. Access to practice sites was strictly limited. These Games are for Canadians, not the world.
While I also have reservations about the Own the Podium program - in particular the nationalistic fervor it appeals to, it's hard nonetheless not to suspect an underlying thread of resentment in the Barnes' article. After all the former colonial outpost has topped GB convincingly when it comes to medal count... a total of 26 to Britain's one. Moreover fourteen of the Canadian medals are gold. The Brit ego is bound to be stinging. But wait, according to Barnes the English are above such low-minded partisan attitudes. He says: "The idea of being brought up in resentment is foreign to English nature. No doubt we have faults in the opposite direction, but we have a very low tolerance of chippiness."
Ahem... that's a little rich to say the least. The English can be as petty as the best of them, it's just that they're often better at hiding it... a bit like Simon actually.
Own the Podium, corporate patrons, the politics-of-the-games and other nationalistic adrenalin-boosting hype aside, the Canadian success comes down to the men and women who made enormous personal sacrifices to reach this level of athletic excellence. Irrespective of what you think about the Olympics and all it represents - you have to respect that.
Canada is a young country in the process of forging its identity and doubtless the verve and elan that comes with that must be very irksome to an older 'mother' nation that is pretty much in the doldrums these days. A recent survey claims that almost half the population of the UK would like to emigrate given half the chance.
Barnes risks coming off like a scolding aunt. Here for example:
But really, what a way to run a global event. A host shouldn’t treat his guests as gate-crashers. This grudging and inhospitable spirit has been an ugly aspect of Vancouver. The ultimate aim of these Games, any Games, is global excellence and global joy, not provincial victory and local bragging rights.
The Canadians have taken an aggressive line towards any criticism. This kneejerk reaction is both small-minded and small-nation. It is not hostile to point out an error, particularly when the error is rudely thrust in your face.
The writer's high minded call for sporting decency etc comes off as a tad anachronistic these competitive down-and-dirty days. Let's face it, sore losers often resort to rhetoric of a sort they may be less inclined to indulge if their team was walking away with a medal haul. He does make some criticisms worth considering but it's where its coming from that gives pause.
Barnes wraps up on a rather chippy note himself:
"Own The Podium? Own bloody goal, more like".
Okay then. Doubtless on Sunday Simon will be donning his stars and stripes t'shirt as he checks out the hockey final.




































