Stephen Harper denies the Conservative Party of Canada had anything to do with robo-calls and other misleading phone calls made during the 2011 federal election. The calls sent some Canadian voters on a wild goose chase, hunting for "relocated" polling stations that didn't exist.
A disposable cellphone registered to
a mysterious Pierre Poutine of Separatist Street, Joliette, Quebec, featured in the phone scams. Curiously enough the phoney voting location where voters were being steered in Guelph - the Old Quebec Street mall - has a restaurant nearby named Pierre's Poutine.
If you believe Harper, the Conservative Party had nothing to do with any of it.
The scamsters and phone artists who misrepresented themselves, lied about poll locations and harassed the hell out of voters were just a bunch of rogue operators. Maybe even just one guy on speed - a sort of trans-Canada phone magician.
What we do know is that the efforts of these shadow operators to mislead were geared to the benefit of one party, and one party alone - that being the Conservative Party of Canada. Even so, nobody in the party was involved - especially not Harper who has a strategic knack of
not knowing about things he prefers not-to-know-about.
Inconvenient revelations have surfaced that call Harper's claims into question.
Huffington Post:
A Mission, B.C., woman says she was given misleading information by the Conservative Party a few days before the May 2011 federal election.
Astrid Dimond said she had been called six times for Conservative donations during the last election. After a seventh call, she said she did an internet search on the caller’s phone number, which had shown up on her call display.
"It came up as the Conservative Party in Victoria," Dimond said.
The next time she received a call from the same number, she told the caller she was supporting the NDP in the election in the hopes the calls would stop.
Two days before the election, Dimond said she got another call from the same number.
“[The caller] just said, ‘Did you know the polling station had changed,’ and basically, I said, ‘No it hasn't,’ and that was the end of the conversation. I wouldn't let her continue because I knew it was a falsehood."
That's a loose end that might take some explaining. In the meantime speaking of loose ends - according to a CBC report the
Tories are busily reviewing every call made by the Responsive Marketing Group in advance of Election Canada investigators.
If some Tories were indeed in on it in a backdoor "unofficial" capacity, why would they take the risk? Well there was a lot at stake. Harper has been after a parliamentary majority for years. On successive occasions he was denied by Canadians who amazingly enough didn't seem to really trust Harper with a majority that would allow him to take it to the next level in his take-over-of-Canada-plan. Yet another minority in the 2011 federal election would have meant a loss of political face for Harper.
The calls that went out in Guelph and elsewhere were targeted. The Tories have an impressive database on voters - a data Goliath known as the
Constituency Information Management System. It serves up info about Tory backers running all the way from an individual's policy priorities to whether or not someone in say Brampton might be willing to plant a Conservative lawn sign.
It stands to reason that a database used to track supporters could also be used to come up with lists of non-supporters. Certainly Pierre Poutine and associates seemed to to have access to lists and knew exactly who they were calling. One woman in Guelph, a Liberal supporter, noted that a suspect caller asked specifically to speak to her rather than to her husband.
Did the dirty tricks affect the outcome in the ridings? Very possibly. In Nipissing-Timiskaming, Lib incumbent Anthony Rota lost to Tory Jay Aspin by just 18 votes. NDP MP Jim Malloway has candidly stated that dirty tricks played a part in his loss by 300 votes to Conservative Lawrence Toet.
The Green Party's Elizabeth May, has said that she
regards the Saanich-Gulf islands as a "pilot project" for the more recent efforts at voter suppression in Canadian ridings. The Saanich-Gulf incident is worth repeating because it mirrors the more recent shenanigans.
During the 2008 election the NDP candidate in Saanich-Gulf, Julian West, dropped out of the race as a result of revelations about a scandal. West pulled out of the race too late for his name to be removed from the ballot.
Oddly enough NDP voters were then bombarded with calls urging them to vote for West who ended up with a surprising tally of 3,667 votes. This represents 6% of the total, way higher than the 1% a pre-vote poll projected for West. Wasted votes that may otherwise have gone to the Liberal candidate helped ensure Conservative Gary Lunn's victory.
Whether or not these phone tactics and related dirty tricks are found to be criminal remains to be seen. But one thing is clear - they speak to
a contempt for democracy... contempt for the rights of Canadians... contempt for Canadian institutions. They signal that what really matters is control of the agenda and the capacity to retain power at all costs.
Of course none of that is remotely characteristic of Stephen Harper who true-to-form knows nothing about any of it and prefers to cast it all as a Lib/NDP smear job.